Help me choose my new banner!

I'm sick of my old shop banner and wanted to create a new one. The problem is that I have a few that I like, but can't decide which to use.

Banner #1 stones with logo:


Banner #2 stones without logo:


Banner #3 flames:


Banner #4 dots with logo:


Banner #5 dots without logo:


I took down my old banner this morning and put up banner #2 until I decide which one to use. Which one do you like?